Was David Moyes given enough time to prove himself at Manchester United?

Less than a year into his reign as Manchester United manager, David Moyes has been sacked. I for one have thought that this was coming for a long time. I wasn’t someone who wanted Moyes sacked, but I did think it was inevitable. The arguments against the Scot leaving the club were rather weak. “He needs time” would more often than not be the reply from a Moyes supporter if asked if it were time to relieve him of his duty.

david moyes

Time, how long is enough time? I have been in numerous discussions about how long is enough time, two years is the most frequent shout, 18 months, three years, he’s had enough time, the latter comment being the one that has grown the more vocal in the recent months and weeks. Starting his career at United, David Moyes expected that he would have time to build his own squad. He expected that he wouldn’t be expected to win the league, win the cups, and dominate in Europe, not just yet anyway. With that said, other expectations were made clear to him. If you believe what the tabloid sports writers say, then qualification for Europe was one.

When Sir Alex left the club, what he left was a shell of a side. The team clearly needed some work done to continue it’s dominance of football in England over the coming years. This is something I can agree with, the squad is clearly not good enough to win the league, the players are a little bit older than last year and in the cases of Rio Ferdinand and Michael Carrick, they probably had one of their best seasons for United last term, and could not be expected to repeat that. Does this mean that the team is where it should be? I don’t think they are, the fall off from being league champions to 7th is far too steep a descent to be considered acceptable.

rooney-moyes-white-shirt

Poor management of players like RVP, Danny Welbeck, Shinji Kagawa, Rafael has resulted in poor seasons for most, and Danny Welbeck reportedly requesting to leave the club. When the team played against Everton on Saturday, the message emanating from the squad was, “I can’t take this anymore, I don’t even know what we’re meant to be doing?”. These problems are what will always stick out in my mind as why David Moyes is no longer Manchester United manager. While Ed Woodward may not have helped Moyes in the transfer dealings last summer, the poor management of the players in his squad have ultimately spelled his doom.

david-moyes-watching

Along with the poor management and disgruntled players, the unwelcomed stats kept rolling in.

1. United have fewer home points in the league than Norwich and Hull.

2. United have scored 22 goals at home, less than Stoke and West Ham.

3. United have lost to Everton for the first time home and away since 1969/1970.

4. United have lost to Everton, Liverpool & Manchester City home and away in the same season for the first time in the clubs history.

5. United have lost at Old Trafford to Swansea for the first time ever.

6. United have lost three games in a row for the first time since 2001.

7. United have lost at Old Trafford to Newcastle for the first time since 1972.

8. United have failed to qualify for the Champions League for the first time since 1995.

9. United are guaranteed to finish the season with the lowest points tally ever in the Premer League era.

I don’t want this to sound like I believe David Moyes is completely incompetent, I actually think he is a good manager but I don’t believe his style was ever going to work at United. As I said at the start, I never wanted him to be fired but I thought it was inevitable. Every part of me wanted him to be a success, but to do that he would have needed to become more adventurous, something I don’t believe he would ever have done.

david moyes

This brings me back to my original point, time. While ten months may seem like to short a term for the manager to really make a difference, the point I’m making is that he didn’t need to improve a great deal. His main objective this season should have been to instill a philosophy in the team, get them and the fans to understand his vision. As the months rolled by there were no signs that Moyes was doing this, or even could do this. At that point, with the summer transfer window looming and a proposed budget of 200m to spend on new players, ten months may have been enough.

This is of course only my opinion. I don’t agree with how the sacking was handled; allowing the media finding out before the man himself. I also think that the opportunity for Moyes was the proverbial poisoned chalice as there was always going to be too many comparisons to Sir Alex. I would not be surprised to see David Moyes move on to a new job next season and be very successful.

The future for United is very complicated; rumors of Van Gaal, Simeone, Mourinho, Giggs, and even Ferguson being the next manager are rife. The only certainty for now is that when the weekend comes and Norwich travel to Old Trafford and Ryan Giggs will be in the dugout as manager and player.

11 Comments

  1. The signs were there since pre-season……..The spotlight was on him…..and his flaws became apparent………He cut short some players careers, and he will do the same again, because he is a ‘know it all, who knows nothing’…I pity the club that sign him, Round and Lumsden…..

  2. Now with DAvy boy gone will rooney take a pay cut big money Meens goals not running about like a headless chicken

  3. He was given loads of ,56games+to show how he can get a team to play well together.He got a lot of stick cause it was United and he was out of his depth.Cant really blame him for Felaini,look at Torres,has,nt done well at Chelsea.IT,s the right decision,it was,nt working out and would have taken too much time.The thing is will the NeXT manager be right one.

  4. Bumpy road ahead for a few years to come as it was said those at the top of . The ladder forget t h at their is a bottom rung so start climbing Manc’s shit

  5. Think manutd are a disgrace to let the press know before moyes.
    Whoever leaked it out should be sacked and moyes backroom staff are a joke.
    Think he should of been given more times as thr next manager will have time and money to build a team.
    good luck to our next manager as he will need it.

  6. I’m unsure. At the moment everybody is all “we told you so” and “it was obvious from the very start”. But fact is just as many of us were looking for all his qualities when we appointed him.

    And for one I don’t think he’s as clueless as everyone seems to be concluding at this point. David Moyes is a very competent and all but conservative football man in my mind. And of course he wasn’t given enough time to make his mark. But that wasn’t due to his lack of abilities.

    As I see it, he tried imposing changes too fast. He took over an extremely well run club and imposed significant changes too fast.

    The back room staff for one. Experienced and popular figures such as Meulensteen and Steele were binned. At the time it seemed gutsy. Moyes making United his own straight away. But in hindsight it was too early for such drastic changes.

    Then there was the obscure handling of fan favorite Patrice Evra. Moyes’ all but secret hunt for Baines imposed insecurity and when it failed it probably didn’t make Moyes look good to the players.

    To me it seemed Moyes lost his composure. Looking back, it seems he should have stretched some of his decisions over a longer period of time.

    The funny thing is that Moyes actually looked the right places to impose his changes.

    Evra has been done for years but managed to redeem himself somewhat last season. Also giving Rio-Vida partnership the axe was right. They’re not world beaters anymore. And buying a central midfielder was also right.

    But he just went the wrong way about it all. Significant changes should have come more gradually to a club that has had the same manager for 26 years. Moyes didn’t bring stability. He brought big changes and uncertainty with him.

    Sadly. Because I would have loved to see him make it.

  7. definitely given enough time. What would be the point of letting him continue into next season when he`s already shown that he can`t manage to keep a team of players who were already winners from sliding to 7th from 1st place.

    There wasn`t the slightest hint that he was ever able to turn it round. Very much out of his depth, both himself and Steve square.

    United need winners to manage them, not a former Everton manager who haven`t won anything in 12 years. He probably worked miracles at Everton , but this is United.

  8. Moyes had enough time to show whether he was up to the job or not. Clearly he is not up to it and giving him more time would just be a waste of time as well damaging United further.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*


Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.