Manchester United’s trip to the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium was supposed to be an opportunity to climb up to 12th in the Premier League table, but instead, it turned into another chapter of frustration and disappointment for Amorim’s side. With a makeshift lineup and a tactical setup that raised eyebrows, United were once again left to rue individual errors and missed chances in a performance that highlighted the team’s ongoing struggles.
Here are three key takeaways from a match that left United fans with more questions than answers.
1. Andre Onana’s Decline Continues to Haunt United
Andre Onana’s arrival at Old Trafford was met with optimism. The Cameroonian goalkeeper, known for his ball-playing ability and commanding presence, was seen as the perfect modern goalkeeper to fit Ten Hag’s system. However, this season has been a stark contrast to those early expectations.
Onana’s decline has been one of the most concerning aspects of United’s campaign. After a solid start, his form has plummeted, and his errors have become increasingly costly. Against Tottenham, he was once again at fault for the opening goal. A long-range effort from Spurs should have been dealt with comfortably, but Onana’s weak parry fell straight into the path of James Maddison, who tapped home with ease.
This isn’t the first time Onana’s mistakes have cost United points. His calamitous performance against Brighton earlier in the season was a low point, and his inability to command his area or instil confidence in his defence has become a recurring theme. With the summer transfer window looming, United now face a dilemma. Limited funds and multiple areas of the squad needing reinforcement mean that signing a new first-choice goalkeeper may not be straightforward. However, for many supporters, it has become an undeniable necessity.
2. Alejandro Garnacho’s Wastefulness in Front of Goal
Alejandro Garnacho burst onto the scene last season with his electrifying pace and fearless attacking play, earning him a reputation as one of United’s most exciting young talents. However, this season has been a different story for the Argentine winger.
Garnacho’s form has deserted him at a time when United need him most. His last goal came in November against Bodo/Glimt, and his drought in domestic competitions stretches even further back. Against Tottenham, he was handed two golden opportunities to make an impact but failed to capitalise on either.
The first came midway through the first half when he found himself in a prime position to equalise. With the goal at his mercy, Garnacho inexplicably blazed his effort over the bar. It was a moment that summed up his recent struggles in front of goal. Later in the second half, he was presented with another one-on-one chance but again failed to convert.
At just 20 years old, Garnacho’s potential is undeniable, but United cannot afford to carry passengers in their quest for consistency. With Amad Diallo likely sidelined for the remainder of the season, Garnacho needs to rediscover his form quickly. His talent is evident, but talent alone isn’t enough at a club of United’s stature.
3. Joshua Zirkzee’s Gradual Improvement Offers a Glimmer of Hope
Amid the gloom of another disappointing result, there was a small silver lining in the form of Joshua Zirkzee. The Dutch forward, who joined United in the summer, has had a mixed start to life at Old Trafford. However, against Tottenham, he showed signs of growing into his role and adapting to the demands of English football.
Operating as one of the two number 10s behind Rasmus Hojlund, Zirkzee displayed some neat touches and intelligent link-up play. He was United’s most consistent attacking threat on the night, often dropping deep to collect the ball and driving forward with purpose. While he was guilty of a poor miss with an unmarked header, his overall performance was encouraging.
Zirkzee’s gradual improvement is a positive sign for United, especially given the injury crisis that has decimated their forward line. With limited options available, the 23-year-old now has the chance to stake his claim for a regular starting spot. His ability to adapt and grow in confidence could prove crucial as United look to salvage something from a turbulent season.
A Night to Forget, but Lessons to Learn
Manchester United’s defeat to Tottenham was a microcosm of their season so far – disjointed, error-prone, and lacking in cutting edge. While individual performances from the likes of Zirkzee offered a glimmer of hope, the broader issues within the squad were laid bare once again.
Andre Onana’s struggles, Garnacho’s wastefulness, and the ongoing tactical inconsistencies are problems that Amorim must address if United are to turn their season around. The road ahead is fraught with challenges, but performances like this serve as a stark reminder of the work that still needs to be done.
As the Red Devils prepare for their next fixture, the focus must be on learning from these mistakes and building a foundation for the future. For now, the frustration continues, but the hope remains that brighter days are on the horizon.
What did you make of United’s performance against Tottenham? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below or on our social media channels.
