Manchester United’s Kobbie Mainoo emerged as one of the few bright sparks in an otherwise dismal 2023/24 season for the club. The teenager’s breakthrough under Erik ten Hag was a rare silver lining in a campaign that saw United slump to an eighth-place finish in the Premier League—their lowest in decades. Mainoo’s composure, technical ability, and maturity beyond his years earned him widespread acclaim, and he quickly became a mainstay in the starting XI.
However, the arrival of Ruben Amorim as United’s new manager has raised questions about Mainoo’s role in the team. The 19-year-old, who played a pivotal part in United’s FA Cup triumph and England’s run to the Euro 2024 final, has struggled to replicate his best form this season. Injuries have played their part, but so too has Amorim’s tactical experimentation, which has left Mainoo looking unsettled and, according to Paul Scholes, “lost.”
Scholes’ Concerns: A Legend’s Perspective
Speaking on The Overlap Fan Debate, Scholes didn’t hold back in his assessment of Mainoo’s current predicament. The United legend expressed his belief that the young midfielder is being misused under Amorim’s system, leaving him unsure of his role on the pitch.
“I think Mainoo is lost,” Scholes said. “I’ve talked about Declan Rice being lost before—I think Mainoo is lost as well. They don’t know what to do with him.”
Scholes went on to highlight the confusion surrounding Mainoo’s position, pointing out that Amorim has deployed him in multiple roles without finding a natural fit. “I don’t think he knows where to play on a football pitch because he’s been played in one of the number 10 positions, he has been played in the two in the midfield, which I can see probably doesn’t suit him because I don’t think he’s the greatest athlete.”
While Scholes acknowledged Mainoo’s technical qualities, he was critical of the decision to use him as a false nine during United’s 2-0 defeat to Crystal Palace—a move that backfired spectacularly. “He’s a great footballer. I think the No 10 does suit him, (but) the false nine, never in a million years.”
Mainoo’s Rise and Recent Struggles
Mainoo’s rise to prominence last season was nothing short of remarkable. Breaking into the first team under Ten Hag, he quickly established himself as a key player with his ability to dictate play, break up opposition attacks, and contribute in both defensive and offensive phases. His goal in the FA Cup final against Manchester City, which helped secure a 2-1 victory, was a defining moment in his young career.
On the international stage, Mainoo continued to shine, playing a crucial role in England’s journey to the Euro 2024 final. His performances on such a grand stage only reinforced the belief that he was destined for greatness.
However, this season has been a different story. Injuries have disrupted his rhythm, and Amorim’s tactical tinkering has left him without a clear role. Mainoo has been tried in various positions—as a deep-lying midfielder, an advanced playmaker, and even as a false nine—but none have fully capitalised on his strengths.
Amorim’s Tactical Dilemma
Amorim’s arrival at Old Trafford was met with optimism, given his success with Sporting CP and his reputation as one of Europe’s most innovative young managers. However, his attempts to integrate Mainoo into his system have so far yielded mixed results.
The Portuguese coach’s preference for fluid, positionally flexible football has seen Mainoo shuffled around the pitch, often leaving him isolated or out of sync with his teammates. The experiment of using him as a false nine against Crystal Palace was particularly puzzling, as it negated his ability to influence the game from deeper areas.
While Amorim’s willingness to experiment is commendable, there is a growing sense that Mainoo’s development is being hindered by the lack of a defined role. For a player of his talent and potential, consistency and clarity are crucial.
The Road Ahead
As United prepare to face Tottenham Hotspur on Sunday, all eyes will be on Mainoo and how he fits into Amorim’s plans. The match represents an opportunity for the young midfielder to rediscover his form and silence his critics, but it also raises broader questions about his future at the club.
Scholes’ comments have sparked a wider debate about how best to utilise Mainoo’s talents. Should Amorim persist with his experiments, or would it be more beneficial to build the team around Mainoo in a role that maximises his strengths?
For now, Mainoo remains one of United’s most promising assets, but his development must be handled with care. As Scholes’ remarks suggest, there is a risk of stalling his progress if the current uncertainty continues.
A Star in the Making, But at What Cost?
Kobbie Mainoo’s journey from academy prospect to first-team regular has been a source of hope for United fans during a turbulent period. His talent is undeniable, but his recent struggles highlight the challenges young players face when adapting to new systems and expectations.
Paul Scholes’ critique, while harsh, underscores the importance of finding the right role for Mainoo. As United look to rebuild and challenge for silverware under Amorim, the handling of their young star could prove pivotal.
For now, the message is clear: Kobbie Mainoo is a special talent, but he needs the right environment to thrive. Whether Amorim can provide that remains to be seen.
