Paul Scholes, a name synonymous with Manchester United’s golden era, has never been one to shy away from expressing his views, no matter how controversial they may be. His latest comments on Lisandro Martinez, however, have stirred the pot in a way that has left the United fanbase divided. Speaking on The Overlap, Scholes delivered a blunt assessment of the Argentine defender, stating, “Even if Lisandro is healthy, he is not good enough for a Premier League-winning team.”
These words, coming from a club legend, have sparked a fiery debate among supporters and pundits alike. While some have echoed Scholes’ sentiments, others have rushed to Martinez’s defense, highlighting the unique qualities he brings to Erik ten Hag’s side. Martinez, for his part, was quick to respond, taking to social media with a biting retort: “This jinx guy is really hurting… You put him in Argentina, and he wouldn’t survive.”
The exchange has not only reignited discussions about Martinez’s role at United but has also brought to light the broader question of what it takes to succeed in the Premier League.
Paul Scholes: "Even if Lisandro is healthy, he is not good enough for a Premier League winning team."
— All About Argentina 🛎🇦🇷 (@AlbicelesteTalk) February 11, 2025
📲 Lisandro responds: "This jinx guy is really hurting….You put him in Argentina, and he wouldn’t survive." pic.twitter.com/aesgyBD4Pu
Martinez: A Modern Defender with a Unique Skill Set
Since his arrival at Old Trafford, Lisandro Martinez has been a polarising figure. Standing at just 5’9”, his height has often been cited as a potential weakness, particularly in a league known for its physicality and aerial duels. Yet, Martinez has consistently defied these criticisms with his intelligence, tenacity, and technical prowess.
Martinez is widely regarded as one of the finest ball-playing defenders in the Premier League. His ability to break opposition lines with precise passing, coupled with his composure under pressure, has made him a linchpin in United’s build-up play. Often operating as a quasi-midfielder, Martinez’s vision and range of passing allow him to dictate the tempo of the game from deep, a trait that has become increasingly valuable in modern football.
His partnership with Raphael Varane has been instrumental in United’s defensive structure, providing a balance of experience, athleticism, and tactical intelligence. Martinez’s aggressive style of defending, while occasionally leading to moments of recklessness, has also been a key factor in his success. His willingness to step out of the defensive line to intercept passes or engage in tackles has disrupted countless opposition attacks, earning him the admiration of fans and teammates alike.
Scholes’ Critique: Fair or Unfair?
Scholes’ comments, however, have cast a shadow over Martinez’s contributions. The former midfielder’s assertion that Martinez is not fit for a title-winning side has raised eyebrows, particularly given the Argentine’s impact since joining the club. While it’s true that Martinez has had his share of mistakes—moments of over-commitment and lapses in concentration—these are not uncommon for a defender who plays on the front foot.
The timing of Scholes’ remarks has also been called into question. Martinez is currently recovering from a serious ACL injury, a setback that has kept him sidelined for much of the season. For a player already facing the physical and mental challenges of rehabilitation, such criticism could be seen as unnecessarily harsh.
It’s worth noting that Scholes’ perspective may be shaped by his own experiences at United, where he played alongside defensive stalwarts like Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic. These were players who not only excelled in one-on-one duels but also possessed the physical attributes to dominate in the air. In contrast, Martinez’s game is built on anticipation, positioning, and technical ability—qualities that may not always align with traditional notions of what makes a top-class defender.
The Broader Context: United’s Defensive Woes
Scholes’ critique of Martinez must also be viewed within the context of United’s broader defensive struggles this season. The team has been plagued by inconsistency, with injuries and tactical changes disrupting the backline’s cohesion. Martinez’s absence has been keenly felt, with his replacements often failing to replicate his influence on the pitch.
This raises an important question: Is Martinez truly not good enough for a title-winning team, or is he simply a victim of United’s current transitional phase? The answer may lie somewhere in between. While Martinez has undoubtedly been one of United’s standout performers, the team as a whole has yet to reach the level required to challenge for the Premier League title.
A Fiery Response and What It Means
Martinez’s response to Scholes’ comments has only added fuel to the fire. By referring to Scholes as a “jinx guy” and suggesting that he wouldn’t survive in Argentine football, Martinez has not only defended his own abilities but has also taken a swipe at Scholes’ credibility as a pundit. This kind of fiery retort is indicative of Martinez’s character—a player who thrives on adversity and is unafraid to stand up for himself.
For United fans, this exchange is a reminder of the passion and intensity that defines the club. Scholes, as a legend, will always have a platform to voice his opinions, but Martinez’s response shows that the current generation of players are equally determined to make their mark.
The Road Ahead
As Martinez continues his recovery and works towards returning to full fitness, the spotlight will remain firmly on him. Can he silence his critics and prove Scholes wrong? Only time will tell. What is certain, however, is that Martinez’s journey at United is far from over. His technical ability, leadership qualities, and fighting spirit make him a vital asset for the team, and his contributions will be crucial as United look to rebuild and challenge for silverware in the coming seasons.
In the meantime, the war of words between Scholes and Martinez has added an extra layer of intrigue to United’s campaign. Whether this clash of opinions will galvanise the team or create further tension remains to be seen. One thing is for sure: the Red Devils’ faithful will be watching closely, ready to rally behind their players as they strive for success.
As the old adage goes, “Form is temporary, class is permanent.” For Lisandro Martinez, the opportunity to prove his class—and prove his doubters wrong—is still very much within reach.
